A frightening Dystopian Novel.
“What mattered were individual relationships, and a completely helpless gesture, an embrace, a tear, a word spoken to a dying man, could have value in itself” Winston Smith
.
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
#1: Part 1-What is Winston Smith's world like? How does he feel about it?
Abdullah Islam - Winston Smith lives in a fictional London where everybody is under the control of The Party and Big Brother and its seems like the rest of the world is at war with each other. The Party watches everybody and doesn't like individuality or any sort of rebellious action towards the Party. Winston seems to hate the Party and feels frustrated at his inability to change anything.
From the first few chapters, Winston Smith can be described as a person who will inevitably encounter a psychotic episode from being constantly watched by the Thought Police. He is taught to not acknowledge creativity, but he defies this and starts to write journal entries to a generation he will never have the chance of knowing. I suppose that the "varicose ulcer that had begun itching unbearably" (8) is causing him to become insubordinate and he seems to not only care about his future, but also what is capable of doing while he still has the time to be rebellious. He decides to make the most of his limited independence by dodging from the forces of higher authority and continuing to write down his present so that this example of a controlled society would not repeat.
Good point Morgan. I think Winston is parnoid with the ubiquitous presence of BB...he is always watching--and the telescreens--Our world is similar to Winstons...His writing and journal are a form of rebellion--but he knows it means "death".
Winston Smith lives in a nation called Oceania that is run by an oppressive government ruled by the Party and Big Brother. This dictatorial government watches and hears everything the people do or say, prohibiting them from thinking for themselves. Winston at first flips from hating Big Brother to admiring him, but over time he comes to just resent him for the power he holds over everyone.
Thanks for the post Philomena--Winston loves and hates BB--as evidence with the Two Minutes of Hate and then his journal writing..BB suppresses and controls the feelings and behavior by way of surveillance and fear.
Maia Bankhead-Winston Smith's world is a so-called place of "no rules," but in reality its limitations are the line between life and death. With Big Brother constantly watching, people are simply told to accept him as a leader despite never seeing him in person, so he might not even exist. There are actions that can get a person removed-eccentricities like talking to yourself-and when said person is removed everyone is expected to go on like that person never existed. This is a constant thing seen throughout the first few chapters. Winston's job is basically rewriting history by changing newspapers so they're in BB's favor. There are obviously people older than Winston, we vaguely has memories of a different time, but they and everyone else acts like BB has always been around or life was far worse beforehand. However, no one could ever know for sure. Winston is obviously paranoid and has a love-hate feeling towards BB. He has grown up knowing the culture, so he's obviously going to love Big Brother to some degree, but at the same time he remembers a different time, no matter how shortly, and that fills his mind with doubt. He struggles with newspeak and keeps journal for a generation without this type of government hoping that that day will come. However, he's scared, which he showed with the journal when he started rambling and is afraid of the dark-haired girl.
Question: when Mrs.Parson's son shoots Winston in the back of the head with a hot metal rod, is that an example of foreshadowing? (I am on chapter 3, just curious)
Winston Smith despises the dystopian society he lives in. "Big Brother" the dictator of Oceania, where Winston lives, is head of "The Party" which resembles a modern day congress. Big Brother monitors every citizens thoughts and programs parents own children to report if someone, even if their family says something to go against The Party. When Mrs. Parson’s children wanted to see someone get hanged I was astonished, the fact that they were demanded to see this act of viscous cruelty with ages before double digits shows how brainwashing The Party, Thought Police, Big Brother and even the Oceania schools children attend must be. In Oceania, people are forced to wear clothing based on what job they did, and are constantly monitored every second of the day by a television that records and microphones. Life is extremely demanding in Oceania, and there is no privacy. Even as much as a swift movement of the hand could cause an average citizen to be killed. Winston is trying to repudiate this government without breaking any codes of conduct, although there aren't any laws in Oceania you can still be forced to perform acts of bone-breaking manual labor, or you will be shot in the neck by the thought police. Winston is attempting to release his rebellious motives by writing in his "Diary" and speaking of events from the past. The novel really picks up once Winston writes "Down with Big Brother" and the reader begins to feel very anxious to continue reading.
Abdullah Islam - Winston Smith lives in a fictional London where everybody is under the control of The Party and Big Brother and its seems like the rest of the world is at war with each other. The Party watches everybody and doesn't like individuality or any sort of rebellious action towards the Party. Winston seems to hate the Party and feels frustrated at his inability to change anything.
ReplyDeleteAbdullah--an insighful obervation. How is Winston's situation like yours? Are you frustrated with things that you cannot change?
DeleteFrom the first few chapters, Winston Smith can be described as a person who will inevitably encounter a psychotic episode from being constantly watched by the Thought Police. He is taught to not acknowledge creativity, but he defies this and starts to write journal entries to a generation he will never have the chance of knowing. I suppose that the "varicose ulcer that had begun itching unbearably" (8) is causing him to become insubordinate and he seems to not only care about his future, but also what is capable of doing while he still has the time to be rebellious. He decides to make the most of his limited independence by dodging from the forces of higher authority and continuing to write down his present so that this example of a controlled society would not repeat.
ReplyDeleteGood point Morgan. I think Winston is parnoid with the ubiquitous presence of BB...he is always watching--and the telescreens--Our world is similar to Winstons...His writing and journal are a form of rebellion--but he knows it means "death".
DeleteWinston Smith lives in a nation called Oceania that is run by an oppressive government ruled by the Party and Big Brother. This dictatorial government watches and hears everything the people do or say, prohibiting them from thinking for themselves. Winston at first flips from hating Big Brother to admiring him, but over time he comes to just resent him for the power he holds over everyone.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the post Philomena--Winston loves and hates BB--as evidence with the Two Minutes of Hate and then his journal writing..BB suppresses and controls the feelings and behavior by way of surveillance and fear.
ReplyDeleteMaia Bankhead-Winston Smith's world is a so-called place of "no rules," but in reality its limitations are the line between life and death. With Big Brother constantly watching, people are simply told to accept him as a leader despite never seeing him in person, so he might not even exist. There are actions that can get a person removed-eccentricities like talking to yourself-and when said person is removed everyone is expected to go on like that person never existed. This is a constant thing seen throughout the first few chapters. Winston's job is basically rewriting history by changing newspapers so they're in BB's favor. There are obviously people older than Winston, we vaguely has memories of a different time, but they and everyone else acts like BB has always been around or life was far worse beforehand. However, no one could ever know for sure.
ReplyDeleteWinston is obviously paranoid and has a love-hate feeling towards BB. He has grown up knowing the culture, so he's obviously going to love Big Brother to some degree, but at the same time he remembers a different time, no matter how shortly, and that fills his mind with doubt. He struggles with newspeak and keeps journal for a generation without this type of government hoping that that day will come. However, he's scared, which he showed with the journal when he started rambling and is afraid of the dark-haired girl.
Question: when Mrs.Parson's son shoots Winston in the back of the head with a hot metal rod, is that an example of foreshadowing?
ReplyDelete(I am on chapter 3, just curious)
Winston Smith despises the dystopian society he lives in. "Big Brother" the dictator of Oceania, where Winston lives, is head of "The Party" which resembles a modern day congress. Big Brother monitors every citizens thoughts and programs parents own children to report if someone, even if their family says something to go against The Party. When Mrs. Parson’s children wanted to see someone get hanged I was astonished, the fact that they were demanded to see this act of viscous cruelty with ages before double digits shows how brainwashing The Party, Thought Police, Big Brother and even the Oceania schools children attend must be. In Oceania, people are forced to wear clothing based on what job they did, and are constantly monitored every second of the day by a television that records and microphones. Life is extremely demanding in Oceania, and there is no privacy. Even as much as a swift movement of the hand could cause an average citizen to be killed.
ReplyDeleteWinston is trying to repudiate this government without breaking any codes of conduct, although there aren't any laws in Oceania you can still be forced to perform acts of bone-breaking manual labor, or you will be shot in the neck by the thought police. Winston is attempting to release his rebellious motives by writing in his "Diary" and speaking of events from the past. The novel really picks up once Winston writes "Down with Big Brother" and the reader begins to feel very anxious to continue reading.